Custom Cookie Details & Pricing


Cookie Crumbles Co. provides custom cookie services throughout Central, New Jersey.

Cookies are sold by the Baker's Dozen. 

Custom cookies are not only a service, they are also an art!

These cookies are not just something you can simply pick-up at the store. 

They require lots of time, patience, love and effort. 

Cookies are priced by the Baker's Dozen. (13 cookies)

Base cost = $35.00 which includes very simple designs or orders with only 1 or 2 cutter choices.

What increases the cost per baker's dozen?

*Number of designs/cutters/colors

*Water Color or Painting



*Metallic Paints 

**Custom Logos = Special Pricing

Flavor Options

- Classic Sugar Cookie 

- Chocolate Sugar Cookie 

- Chocolate Chip Sugar Cookie 

- Double Chocolate Chip Sugar Cookies

More Flavors Coming Soon!

Required Notice

Please be advised that Cookie Crumbles Co. requires a minimum (2) weeks notice for booking all custom orders. This notice is required to cover the shipping time for new cookie cutters, stencils, or metallic dusts/paints that you may want for your design if we do not already have it in our inventory.

Confirmation of Order

Once your order form is submitted, we will reach out to you to discuss your design ideas and answer any questions you may have. From there, you will receive a quotation via email. To approve the quotation please click the "Accept" button. 

A 50% down deposit is required in order to be scheduled. This deposit is non-refundable.

Once approved, you will receive the invoice which must be paid in full by the due date in order to be able to pick-up your cookies. 

Payments are non-refundable if the order is cancelled.

We accept all credit cards, Venmo, and cash payments.

Shipping & Handling

We do not ship or deliver!

Pick-up can be scheduled upon confirmation of the order.

All orders come individually heat-sealed in a bakery box. Plating can also be provided upon request. 

Packaging and handling are included in the cost of the cookies.

Expedite Fees

In the event of a last minute party:

If we have the availability, we can try to squeeze it in free of charge.

However, an expedite fee of 20% may be applied on large orders.