What You Need To Know About Custom Cookies

Cookie Crumbles Co. provides homemade, custom sugar cookies and other baked goods throughout the state of New Jersey. 

Servsafe Certified Food Handler. 

Our custom cookie service provides you with edible art. These cookies are not just something you can simply pick-up at the store, everything is custom made to order. Decorating these cookies requires lots of time, patience, love and effort.

Below are our cookie pricing & details: 

Our cookies are typically priced by the Baker's Dozen (13 cookies). 

However, we also provide smaller gift sets and single cookies during pop-up sales, or upon request.

Base cost (per dozen)= $42.00 which includes very simple designs, orders with only 1 or 2 cutters, or orders using buttercream frosting.

All custom orders use 3.75" - 4.25" cookie cutters. 

* Most custom orders using royal icing start around $48.00 * 

What increases the cost per baker's dozen?

*Cookie Flavor

*Number of Designs/Cookie Cutters/Icing colors

*Water Color or Hand-Painting

*Airbrushing & Stenciling

*Writing & Calligraphy

*Edible Pearlescent Paints & Edible Glitter Dusts

*Fondant or Modeling Chocolate Decorations 

**Custom Logos = Special Pricing*

Custom Cookies (Individual Cost)

- Mini Cookies (1.5" - 2") = $2.00 - $2.50 Each

- Small Cookies (2.5" - 3") = $3.00 - $3.50 Each

- Medium Cookies (3.5") = $4.00 Each 

- Large Cookies (4" - 4.5") (Most Common) = $4.50 - $6.00 Each

- XL Cookies (5" and up) = $7.00 and up (depending on the size)

- Custom Logo Cookies = $5.00 - $7.00 Each

Every set is custom, meaning that the price is determined upon requesting your order. There is no charge for our consultation and quotation. For questions, please email sales@cookiecrumblesco.com with a description of what you are looking for or a photo of the idea. 

- Traditional Vanilla    (*Most Popular*)

   - Color Variations or Marbled Dough Available

- Chocolate 

- Chocolate Chip 

- Double Chocolate Chip 

- Black Cocoa    (*Customer Favorite*)

- Snickerdoodle

- Pumpkin Spice

- Peppermint Bark

- Funfetti   (Sprinkles May Contain Peanut/Tree Nut Products)

AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST:

- Gluten Free (Contains: Gluten Free 1-to-1 Baking Flour)

- Sugar Free (Diabetic Friendly) *Contains: Truvia Sweeteners 

Royal Icing Flavors: 

- Traditional Vanilla 

- Lemon 

- Almond * (Allergen: tree nut products)

- Marshmallow

Buttercream Frosting:

- Vanilla 

- Lemon

- Chocolate (cannot be colored) 

*These cookies DO NOT contain peanuts or nuts of any kind. 

*ALLERGENS: Contains Egg, Milk & Wheat Products

Please be advised: Our bakeware may have come in contact with nut products at some point.      However, they are thoroughly cleaned between each use. Please let us know if there are any allergies to be concerned about upon placing your order!

We 100% recommend using royal icing for custom cookies because it creates a very flat, smooth, shiny look. This is what you see in most of our custom cookie photos. This icing drys completely hard so it is not easy to mess up a cookie when packaging or stacking. 

However, for a simpler and less expensive option, we now offer buttercream frosting for custom cookies. Buttercream frosting will not dry smooth, it will be bumpy in texture. Buttercream frosting will not dry as hard as royal icing so it is possible that you can squish something when packaging. 

*Decorations using buttercream frosting will be relatively simple compared to the design capabilities you'd have using royal icing. Stenciling, water-color/painting, marker details, and custom logos are NOT available for buttercream frosted cookies.

We don't just make custom sugar cookies! We also offered a wide variety of other baked goods that can be customized, such as cakesicles, cookie cake-toppers, chocolate covered oreos, gourmet cookie sandwiches, oreo truffles, hot cocoa bombs and much more! Take a look at our menu to see what else we offer.

Please be advised that Cookie Crumbles Co. requires a minimum (3) weeks notice for booking all custom orders. This notice is required because this entire custom cookie service takes A LOT of time; it is a multi-day process. This time is also required to cover the shipping time for new cookie cutters, stencils, or metallic dusts/paints that you may want for your design if we do not already have it in our inventory.

Our schedule has been filling up very quickly. We recommend booking as soon as you possibly can to ensure that we can fulfill your order.

Once your order request form is submitted, we will reach out to you to discuss your design details. Upon finalization, we will send you an invoice with actual pricing.

Your order must be paid in full in order to be confirmed & scheduled.

Payments are only 50% refundable if the order is cancelled. 

* This is because we purchase the necessary packaging, labels/tags, cookie cutters, and other decorating materials before your party. We may have also given up the time-slot for your party when others may have requested that same date. This also protects us from last minute cancellation, where we may have already started making your order and cannot re-use the cookies.

**Local pick-up can be scheduled upon confirmation of the order. 

Our address is 47 Edgewood Avenue, Colonia, NJ 07067. 

You will also find this in the top right corner of your invoice.

In some cases local delivery may be accepted, upon request. 

Must be scheduled in advance

Limited Availability.

You must be within 6-7 miles from my location

* Delivery Fees: 

- 1-2 Miles = $5

- 3-5 Miles = $10

- 5-7 Miles = $15

*All orders come individually heat-sealed in a bakery box. Plating can also be provided upon request. 

*Packaging and handling are included in the cost of the cookies.

In the event of a last minute party:

If we have the availability, we can squeeze you in free of charge.

However, an expedite fee of 15% - 20% may be applied to larger orders.

Expedited Delivery fees can range from $15 - $25.